(607) 319-4094Order Online
Order Online (607) 319-4094

Handmade hand pies in Ithaca, NY

Made by hand & baked to perfection!

Flaky, golden hand pies with fillings that celebrate comforting flavors from around the world, made the old-fashioned way with local ingredients and humanely raised meat.

Order OnlineView Menu
  • Gluten-freePlus vegan & vegetarian options
  • LocalLocally sourced ingredients
  • HumaneHumanely raised meat
  • Old-fashionedMade by hand, the way it used to be

Savory and sweet hand pies

We take time to prepare our hand pies the way people did generations ago. We offer gluten-free, vegan and vegetarian options.

A tray of savory hand pies fresh out of the ovenOpen larger
Savory hand pies
Sweet hand piesOpen larger
Sweet hand pies
Cherry hand pies with a sugar glazeOpen larger
Cherry hand pies

Ithaca, NY

You can find us in two locations

Visit our cafe on Trumansburg Road or grab a hand pie downtown at Press Bay Alley.

  • Owners Gabe and Hiroko standing next to the Mama Said Cafe sign on Trumansburg Road

    Mama Said Cafe

    1710 Trumansburg Road, Ithaca, NY 14850 · (607) 319-4094. Mon–Fri 8:30 AM–6 PM, Sat 9 AM–6 PM, Sun 9 AM–3 PM.

    More about our locations
  • Press Bay Alley in downtown Ithaca

    Press Bay Alley

    118 West Green Street, Ithaca, NY 14850 · (607) 280-5941. Tue–Sat 11 AM–6 PM. Closed Sunday and Monday.

    More about our locations
Tray of fresh-baked biscuits

Catering

Yes, we cater!

We'd be happy to discuss your upcoming event or celebration. Fill out our catering form with the details of your event. We'll check our calendar for availability and be in touch with more information.

Request catering

Hungry? Order ahead

Order your hand pies online, or stop by one of our two Ithaca locations.

Order Online (607) 319-4094